What is scarier, it 1990 or it 2017?
Comparing the Scare Factor: IT 1990 vs. IT 2017
Both the 1990 and 2017 adaptations of Stephen King's IT have left lasting impressions on viewers, but their scare factors differ based on style, era, and audience expectations.
IT (1990 Miniseries)
- Atmosphere: Relies heavily on psychological horror, suspense, and the unsettling performance of Tim Curry as Pennywise.
- Era-Appropriate Effects: Contains more subtle, less graphic scares due to television restrictions of the time.
- Nostalgia Factor: Many who watched as children found it terrifying, while modern viewers may find the effects dated.
IT (2017 Film)
- Modern Horror Techniques: Utilizes advanced special effects, intense jump scares, and disturbing imagery for a more visceral experience.
- Atmosphere: Creates a darker, more oppressive mood with graphic visuals and a menacing portrayal of Pennywise by Bill Skarsgård.
- Audience Reception: Generally regarded as scarier by contemporary horror standards due to its more intense and graphic approach.
Which Is Scarier?
IT (2017) is widely considered scarier for most audiences because of its modern horror elements, realistic effects, and more frightening interpretation of Pennywise. However, the 1990 version remains unsettling, especially for those who grew up watching it.
Ultimately, the scarier version depends on personal preferences and what type of horror you find most effective—psychological (1990) or visceral and graphic (2017).